Pages

Showing posts with label pretext. Show all posts
Showing posts with label pretext. Show all posts

Friday, June 11, 2010

Setback in Connecticut

Back in February and March of this year, All of Us or None and its allies celebrated the remarkable progress of the "Ban the Box" legislation in Connecticut, where both chambers passed it unanimously.  Really.  Unanimously.

But it turns out that the unanimous passage of the bill did not end its story there.  Today, Gov. M. Jodi Rell vetoed the bill, saying that (1) the bill is redundant because a state law already prohibits denial of employment solely based on a conviction; and (2) the bill's ambiguity (around the phrase "otherwise qualified") exposes employers to "legal challenge by applicants."

It seems that the governor of the Nutmeg State doesn't get what it means to "ban the box."  Banning the box means to change the existing practice of denying employment based on criminal records under pretext.  Because of increasing vitality of Title VII claims and the like (e.g. the CT law mentioned by the Governor herself), employers are increasingly reluctant to admit to anyone that the reason they refuse to hire a person is her criminal record.  "Ban the Box" exposes this hidden motive by isolating it away from other job-related factors--hence the phrase, "otherwise qualified."

Yes, doing so would expose employers to liability.  But, then, Governor, isn't that the very same liability they are exposed to under that law prohibiting them from denying employment based solely on criminal conviction?