Previously, I noted that the City of Compton banned the box. Yet I later posted an on-going effort to ban the box in Compton. So what happened? The City of Compton had banned the box administratively—that is, without changing its municipal code by passing an ordinance. In other words, it banned the box unofficially by changing the practice of its personnel department and without going through its legislative body, the City Council. So it was as easily reversed with a change in administration. Similarly, the State of California banned the box back in 2010, a few months before the gubernatorial election, by an executive fiat of the out-going governor Schwarzenegger. Like in Compton, the executive "ban the box" in the State of California is therefore precarious. But that's a post for another day.
Today, I am writing to report on the latest development in Compton. We submitted to the City Manger a proposed ordinance to ban the box back in January 2011 and counted Councilwoman Calhoun, along with Councilman Jones, among our supporters. Because the City Council requires a simple majority (3 out of 5) to pass the ordinance, we needed a third vote and had informally confirmed that Councilwoman Arceneaux also supported the ordinance.
Last night, about 20 supporters of the ordinance attended the regular City Council meeting and publicly requested that (1) Mayor Perrodin meet with us to discuss Ban the Box and (2) the Council put the ordinance on the agenda for an up-or-down vote. After our request during the public comment period, Councilwoman Calhoun came out in strong support, immediately followed by Councilwoman Arceneaux. Mayor Perrodin then followed with his support for at least the idea of giving a second chance to people with conviction history, despite the fact that his day job is as an assistant district attorney in the Airport Courthouse.
In the upcoming April 9th election, both Councilwoman Calhoun and Councilman Jones are being challenged for their seats, and we could potentially lose two supporters of Ban the Box. Therefore, it's important that the City Council bring the ordinance to a vote before then. And our fight, for the time being, is to make sure that that happens.
Wednesday, March 9, 2011
Friday, October 22, 2010
UPDATE 2: Los Angeles Ban the Box
Perhaps this post is more appropriately titled "Compton Ban the Box," but there's a good reason that our latest effort to ban the box in Compton is under the LA Ban the Box category.
Over the past several months, organizers and advocates from CBOs in Los Angeles and across the state came together to discuss strategies to ban the box in the City and County of Los Angeles--along with parallel discussions with members of All of Us or None, Los Angeles chapter.
The emerging strategy is a step-by-step momentum building one: (1) ban the box in smaller cities in the County of Los Angeles; (2) ban the box in the City of Los Angeles; and (3) then ban the box in the County of Los Angeles. So Rhonda (a founding member and an organizer for All of Us or None, Compton chapter), along with Melissa (an organizer for All of Us or None, Los Angeles chapter) and Susan (a founding member of All of Us or None, Los Angeles chapter), made an impassioned and reasoned presentation to the Personnel Board of the City of Compton last night. Also in attendance were a small group of supporters, about 10 in all, though no public comment was allowed.
So what are we proposing to the City of Compton? In the order of descending urgency to the membership of All of Us or None, Los Angeles chapter are the need to:
We argue that the troubling intersection of incarceration and unemployment has a primary cause in the unfair hiring practices of employers and a secondary cause in the dilemma faced by people with conviction history in deciding whether to disclose their conviction(s) on an employment application.
Given the limited resource available to most people with conviction history (e.g. a lack of reliable transportation, limited access to reliable means of communication, etc.), it is only rational that they seek to maximize their resource in the most "efficient" manner, i.e. by applying only for jobs that afford a realistic employment opportunity and foregoing what they perceive to be "dead-end" opportunities. The presence of the "Box" signals to them to look elsewhere, resulting in what we now refer to as the psychological barrier. Hence the idea for "Ban the Box." Remove the question. Do a background check only when necessary. And make the process transparent and accessible.
Over the past several months, organizers and advocates from CBOs in Los Angeles and across the state came together to discuss strategies to ban the box in the City and County of Los Angeles--along with parallel discussions with members of All of Us or None, Los Angeles chapter.
The emerging strategy is a step-by-step momentum building one: (1) ban the box in smaller cities in the County of Los Angeles; (2) ban the box in the City of Los Angeles; and (3) then ban the box in the County of Los Angeles. So Rhonda (a founding member and an organizer for All of Us or None, Compton chapter), along with Melissa (an organizer for All of Us or None, Los Angeles chapter) and Susan (a founding member of All of Us or None, Los Angeles chapter), made an impassioned and reasoned presentation to the Personnel Board of the City of Compton last night. Also in attendance were a small group of supporters, about 10 in all, though no public comment was allowed.
So what are we proposing to the City of Compton? In the order of descending urgency to the membership of All of Us or None, Los Angeles chapter are the need to:
- Remove the question about conviction history from the application process altogether;
- Develop clear guidelines to guide consideration of the nexus between a job and conviction(s);
- Check and consider conviction history only after a job offer is made;
- Provide a meaningful opportunity to appeal, including a clear notice of disqualifying conviction(s);
- Add a non-discrimination statement on the job application;
- Identify and announce relevant convictions for each job; and
- Expand Ban the Box to City contractors.
We argue that the troubling intersection of incarceration and unemployment has a primary cause in the unfair hiring practices of employers and a secondary cause in the dilemma faced by people with conviction history in deciding whether to disclose their conviction(s) on an employment application.
Given the limited resource available to most people with conviction history (e.g. a lack of reliable transportation, limited access to reliable means of communication, etc.), it is only rational that they seek to maximize their resource in the most "efficient" manner, i.e. by applying only for jobs that afford a realistic employment opportunity and foregoing what they perceive to be "dead-end" opportunities. The presence of the "Box" signals to them to look elsewhere, resulting in what we now refer to as the psychological barrier. Hence the idea for "Ban the Box." Remove the question. Do a background check only when necessary. And make the process transparent and accessible.
Labels:
Ban the Box,
Compton,
demands,
Los Angeles,
update
Friday, October 1, 2010
A rejected op-ed piece for the LA Times
NOTE: The following was written and submitted to the LA Times as an op-ed piece by All of Us or None, in response to a series of articles the paper published on in-home supportive services. It was promptly rejected--within 24 hours of its submission, in fact. No surprise there, given its critical tone toward the paper. So, instead, I'm publishing it here.
In reporting on the King/Drew Medical Center last year, the LA Times was able to identify few, if any, actual cases of medical negligence attributable to employees with conviction history. Despite this glaring lack of evidence, however, the paper still linked the hospital's employment of people with conviction history to the general failure of the hospital staff to pass competency tests. And, in the current fear-mongering campaign against IHSS providers with conviction history, the LA Times is once again making the case that those of us with conviction history will prey on the sick, the elderly, and the disabled--without any concrete evidence whatsoever to prove this causal link.
The LA Times seems to be banking on the public's likely reaction that the lack of evidence is simply indicative of our "incredible luck," as if it was pure chance that people with conviction history didn't hurt anyone under their care while employed. It's as if it never occurred to the LA Times (or to the public) that this "incredible luck" may be due to the hard work of those that are given a second chance in life. How many abuses of IHSS recipients were reported last year? And how many of those abuses were done by people with conviction history compared to those by people without? Out of over a thousand employees at the King/Drew Medical Center, in fact, there have not been even a handful of confirmed cases where employees with prior conviction harmed patients or co-workers. And, among thousands of IHSS workers, we are not presented with even one confirmed case.
We are living in a society where 1 in 100 people (and 1 in 3 blacks without high school diploma) are currently incarcerated. When they return to our communities, their earning powers will have decreased by 50%--that is, if they can find employment at all. The most substantial barrier to their successful reentry is employment. And the most substantial barrier to their employment is our irrational fear of "them" that the LA Times keeps playing to. As long as the paper remains blind to its own irrational assumptions and fears, the LA Times remains complicit in continuing the vicious cycle of mass incarceration, impoverishment, and alienation.
Wednesday, September 29, 2010
UPDATE 1: Los Angeles Ban the Box
As previously mentioned, on 9/15, representatives from 20 community-based organizations, including Homeboy and NAACP came to the LA Ban the Box strategy conference to discuss how to ban the box in Los Angeles, and we will have our first organizing committee meeting on 10/5--where we will have a further discussion of how to ban the box in the City of Los Angeles first.
Monday, August 2, 2010
Los Angeles Ban the Box
At some point, I will post here the frustrating history of Ban the Box in Los Angeles from 2006 and 2008. If you're wondering why Los Angeles isn't one of those places that "banned the box" so far, it's not for lack of trying on our part. And we're still trying. It's mid-2010, and we're once again pushing to ban the box in Los Angeles.
To that end, we will evaluate our past attempts and formulate a new strategy going forward, this time, with the help of more established civil rights organizations. The strategy meeting with key players will take place next week, and a half-day conference/forum with 40+ community-based organizations is scheduled for 9/15. Stay tuned. Some day soon, Los Angeles will ban the box--along with the rest of this country.
To that end, we will evaluate our past attempts and formulate a new strategy going forward, this time, with the help of more established civil rights organizations. The strategy meeting with key players will take place next week, and a half-day conference/forum with 40+ community-based organizations is scheduled for 9/15. Stay tuned. Some day soon, Los Angeles will ban the box--along with the rest of this country.
UPDATE: Connecticut Ban the Box 10-minute clip
GritTV did a segment on the history of Ban the Box in Connecticut, previously discussed here and here.
More GRITtv
More GRITtv
Monday, July 19, 2010
Ban the Box to date
Recently, the National Employment Law Project (NELP), along with the National League of Cities (NLC), published a strategy guide entitled "Cities Pave the Way: Promising Reentry Policies that Promote Local Hiring of People with Criminal Records," which highlights the Ban the Box effort across the country to date.
Twenty-three cities and counties — from Norwich, Conn., and Worcester, Mass., to Austin, Texas, and Alameda County, Calif. — have now implemented ban-the-box policies, deferring criminal background checks to the end of the hiring process and creating a level playing field for all job applicants. In the past year, three states — Connecticut, Minnesota and New Mexico — have adopted similar policies that apply to state employment.
Friday, June 25, 2010
UPDATE: Connecticut Ban the Box
So the Connecticut legislature overrode the veto by Governor Jodi Rell last week and passed Ban the Box. It seems, however, that the media just can't help themselves when an opportunity for fear-mongering presents itself. Hartford Business claims "C[onnecticut] putting veil on jobhunters' criminal pasts" in the title of its article, only to explain later that "Once an applicant is deemed qualified, however, a criminal background check will still be conducted." (emphasis mine).
Wednesday, June 23, 2010
Good news from Memphis, TN
Another good news from the South. The City of Memphis in the State of Tennessee has banned the box. The reporter identifies the measure as "Ban the Box" without mentioning All of Us or None as with previous articles about other cities. I think it's safe to say that "Ban the Box" has become a movement on its own.
Ex-convicts now have one less “X” to mark when filling out a job application for the City of Memphis. Members of Memphis City Council voted to get rid of a section or box on its job applications which requires job hunters to disclose their criminal history. It’s being called “Ban the Box.”
Monday, June 21, 2010
News from Detroit, MI (and beyond)
A piece of good news to start the week off with.
Michigan Policy Network reports that Detroit City Council is thinking about banning the box in their city, along with the City of Lansing. And it lists as having banned the box,
Michigan Policy Network reports that Detroit City Council is thinking about banning the box in their city, along with the City of Lansing. And it lists as having banned the box,
Michigan cities of Kalamazoo and Battle Creek, major U.S. cities including: Baltimore, Boston, Chicago, Minneapolis, San Francisco, Seattle, not to mention the states of New York, Pennsylvania, Wisconsin, Hawaii, Minnesota and New Mexico.
Friday, June 11, 2010
Setback in Connecticut
Back in February and March of this year, All of Us or None and its allies celebrated the remarkable progress of the "Ban the Box" legislation in Connecticut, where both chambers passed it unanimously. Really. Unanimously.
But it turns out that the unanimous passage of the bill did not end its story there. Today, Gov. M. Jodi Rell vetoed the bill, saying that (1) the bill is redundant because a state law already prohibits denial of employment solely based on a conviction; and (2) the bill's ambiguity (around the phrase "otherwise qualified") exposes employers to "legal challenge by applicants."
It seems that the governor of the Nutmeg State doesn't get what it means to "ban the box." Banning the box means to change the existing practice of denying employment based on criminal records under pretext. Because of increasing vitality of Title VII claims and the like (e.g. the CT law mentioned by the Governor herself), employers are increasingly reluctant to admit to anyone that the reason they refuse to hire a person is her criminal record. "Ban the Box" exposes this hidden motive by isolating it away from other job-related factors--hence the phrase, "otherwise qualified."
Yes, doing so would expose employers to liability. But, then, Governor, isn't that the very same liability they are exposed to under that law prohibiting them from denying employment based solely on criminal conviction?
But it turns out that the unanimous passage of the bill did not end its story there. Today, Gov. M. Jodi Rell vetoed the bill, saying that (1) the bill is redundant because a state law already prohibits denial of employment solely based on a conviction; and (2) the bill's ambiguity (around the phrase "otherwise qualified") exposes employers to "legal challenge by applicants."
It seems that the governor of the Nutmeg State doesn't get what it means to "ban the box." Banning the box means to change the existing practice of denying employment based on criminal records under pretext. Because of increasing vitality of Title VII claims and the like (e.g. the CT law mentioned by the Governor herself), employers are increasingly reluctant to admit to anyone that the reason they refuse to hire a person is her criminal record. "Ban the Box" exposes this hidden motive by isolating it away from other job-related factors--hence the phrase, "otherwise qualified."
Yes, doing so would expose employers to liability. But, then, Governor, isn't that the very same liability they are exposed to under that law prohibiting them from denying employment based solely on criminal conviction?
Labels:
Ban the Box,
Connecticut,
Jodi Rell,
pretext,
Title VII
Thursday, June 3, 2010
YJC "bans the box" in the City of LA GRYD Summer Jobs program
The Los Angeles Mayor's Office of Gang Reduction and Youth Development (GRYD) launched an anti-gang initiative called "Summer Night Lights" back in 2008 and hires the youth in local neighborhoods to staff the program. Ironically enough, it originally called for screening out youths on the City's gang database or gang injunctions.
The Youth Justice Coalition (YJC) this week successfully persuaded the GRYD to lift its ban on "registered" gang members. It's a small but significant victory, as the YJC is quick to point out. To quote:
The Youth Justice Coalition (YJC) this week successfully persuaded the GRYD to lift its ban on "registered" gang members. It's a small but significant victory, as the YJC is quick to point out. To quote:
Hopefully this victory will lead the city and county to remove questions asking about convictions and other discriminatory language from additional job, housing and service applications. The YJC is proud to be a part of All Of Us Or None, which is building a national movement uniting formerly incarcerated people to fight for an end to discrimination, including pushing government and private companies to ban the box inquiring about convictions from job applications.My respect to y'all, YJC. You are an example to us all.
Wednesday, May 26, 2010
City of Compton bans the box
Back in the beginning of 2009, All of Us or None, Los Angeles Chapter met with top-level officials from the City of Compton to ban the box at the city level with an active help from a city councilwoman, Barbara Calhoun. Quietly, without much fanfare, the city recently implemented our "ban the box" proposal, removing the question regarding people's criminal history from its online employment application. Given the difficulty we've been having in Los Angeles in persuading the County of Los Angeles and the City of Los Angeles to ban the box, this victory is very encouraging. We'd like to thank Councilwoman Calhoun, along with all the city officials in getting behind the movement and leading the way in Southern California.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)